
Whit if is a collection of poetry that roughly skims over the course of Scottish history, treading the familiar paths of the national narrative, as well as taking some detours down lesser-known routes. However, Whit If is not a book that need be thought of as being exclusively for Scottish History buffs. McMillan’s poetic style is playful, engaging, and humorous enough that anyone could pick it up and enjoy reading it. However, when reading Whit If? it is difficult to escape the sense that, if you are not a student of Scottish history, you are not always going to be getting the fullest experience. Whit If? is reminiscent of the now iconic 1066 And All That, written by W. C. Sellar and R. J. Yeatman, which as a history was never half as funny as it was when read as a comment on the British public education system by those who had been put through it. Equally, Whit If? is as much about our relationship and perception of the past as it is about the past itself. The direction of the address is repeatedly towards the reader. McMillan, and occasionally those historical figures the book focuses on, are asking you, the reader, a question: ‘whit if?’
Whit If? is an easy read. It shares a particular tongue-in-cheek tone with 1066 And All That, but much like that work, it also makes use of the way history is taught and described to society to establish a convenient structure for itself. Starting off, appropriately ‘Afore History’, moving through ‘the Meedle Ages’, and travelling via ‘the Seiventeenth an Aichteenth centuries’. Each section, each mini epoch is prefaced with a short introduction, setting the historical scene, with some wit to help the history along. The poetry itself is snappy and lyrical, and says what it needs to say, pauses for a laugh, and moves on. This keeps everything moving quite nicely, but you do occasionally regret that you cannot linger on to hear more about the Picts or Romans; that is unfortunately the price you must pay for scope and variety.
For the most part, the pieces enjoy a pleasantly jocular and offbeat tone. Yet where the work becomes more serious it is more impactful thanks to its deviation from this chirpy outline. McMillan is adept at scattering amongst the levity a selection of more serious works, apt for more serious topics. It would doubtless be more convenient for a book of comic poems to skim over uncomfortable topics, but when the subject is a nation’s relationship with its own history, doing so would bankrupt the entire project. McMillan includes the disquieting alongside the comic, just how as in real history horror sits alongside humour, and cruelty is compassion’s bedfellow. History is complicated, and Whit If? does not pretend otherwise, though it does have its biases.
As noted, you don’t need a background in Scottish history to appreciate Whit If?. Still, without it, some of the references may seem quite obscure. Several of the hits are here: Picts, Romans, John Knox, etc. However, you may find yourself reaching for your encyclopaedias when you come across Baldred Bisset, The Great Michael or Christina Bruce. That is part of the point, perhaps. Not simply sticking to the popular songs but including the lesser-known back catalogue of Scottish history as an education for the crowd, and a treat for devoted fans.
McMillan’s work is amusing, insightful and scatters plenty of bitter moments among the sweetness, helping to maintain an entertaining palate for the reader. The illustrations by Bob Dewar are terrific. They elevate the experience for the reader, as Dewar demonstrates his ability to illustrate both the uncanny and the comic and provides a good degree of visual interest. Politics are not far from the background throughout. If you are looking for it, it is certainly there.
Among historians, it will probably prompt a good deal of debate, clicking of tongues, and puffing of lips – on all sides, and for reasons none of them will be able to agree on. That is, however, no small part of the point. To say “you do not have to be a historian to read this” is a caveat said in the tone of “you don’t have to be crazy to work here, but it helps”. Anyone can pick up Whit If? and enjoy it, but those with an active interest in Scottish history, politics, and the way we engage with those topics, will find more meat on the bone to chew than those simply looking for a few amusing verses. Whit If?’s good humour, breezy tone, and sheer enthusiasm for its subject matter ensures that any reader will get something out of Whit If? even if it is simply some obscure point of history to debate.
Whit If? is published by Luath Press

